- Downloading a song you don't own from a struggling independent artist.
I think downloading a song is either acceptable or not, regardless of whether the artist is from a major label or if the artist is a struggling independent one. While many people today like to bash major mainstream artists, they forget that at one time they were also struggling and independent. Why should people hate on artists who have spent their lives working hard to rise about? It’s not fair to say that its better to download from a major artist than from an indie artist because even though they can afford to have people download their music for free they still worked very hard to become who they are today. Although I personally believe that downloading music isn’t too wrong, I have also never been an artist who’s lost money from downloading. I think downloading is bad but I still do it because it’s very easy and free. I don’t think it’s any different to download from a major or independent artist. Also independent artists can benefit from downloading because it’s like free advertising.
- Downloading another copy of a song you already own.
I think it is pretty acceptable to download another copy of a song you own because today technology is changing and evolving really fast and it’s not fair to pay an artist many times over for one song that you’ve wanted. They produced one song, and we should be able to personally have and listen to that song no matter how much technology changes. Also, sometimes the quality of disks tapes cassettes etc can degenerate and we should not have to pay 20 dollars again for another hunk of plastic that might break again. I like to copy music to my computer after I buy the cd, I’m not trying to share it etc, it’s just so I can have it with me and I can put it into a play list etc. I’m not trying to cheat the artist so I believe it’s acceptable for me to download another copy. Also, if I’m not at home and I’ve forgotten my cd, I should be able to listen to it.
- Shoplifting a CD from a store.
I think it’s wrong to shoplift a CD from a store. First off, many people suffer from shoplifting. People who work at the store, the store, etc, people lose money from people stealing. Also, a CD is a tangible object. It’s just like an orange from a grocery store or a book from a book store, it’s wrong to steal from a store where people are supposed to pay money in exchange for goods.
- Downloading a song to "try it out" - if you like it enough, you'll buy the CD.
This is perfectly fine, it’s just like the music clips on itunes and amazon.com that lets you sample before you buy, only if you download a song you hear the whole thing and not just one part of it that may nor may not correctly represent the entire song. How can an artist bitch about this scenario if you end of buying their damned CD?
- Copying a CD from a friend.
I think copying a CD from a friend is less acceptable but still ok-ish. For example, if I buy a copy of a CD for my girlfriend, I shouldn’t have to buy another copy just for myself. I’m almost always with her and it’s not fair if I have to pay double the price just to have a copy with me just in case I want to listen to it when I’m alone.
- Making your music available online to share with a couple of friends.
I think it’s ok to share music with your friends, because it’s not like you’re supplying the nation with free music. Sharing music with friends like almost like you’re sharing expressions with people close to you. For example I always tell friends about new songs I like and vice versa, if they’re going to go sample or download it anyways I might as well make my music available to them online.
- Making your music publically available on the Internet, such as through KazAa or Limewire.
I have very undecided feelings about publicly sharing music on the internet. It seems wrong to give many people free music, but at the same time I download music so it’s hard to judge the people who supply me. I think artists themselves should make their music downloadable for a certain, reasonable price. Of course the music files should be cheaper than CD’s seeing as they are not on a solid, tangible object, and it would cost must less to have downloadable music than to produce CD’s.
